Flawed heroes: "Cyrano De Bergerac" and "The Whale"

Sometimes, we allow even minor physical flaws to represent all our failings.

The hero in "Cyrano De Bergerac," at the Roundabout's American Airlines Theatre through  November 25th, allows his comically large nose to be an impediment to his happiness.

Cyrano (Douglas Hodge) does not suffer fools. He triumphs with his sabre-sharp intelligence and sharper sword. It is his generous heart and animated wit that that command the loyalty of his regiment as well as of his fellow poets and gad-abouts.

Samuel Roukin as Valvert and Douglas Hodge as Cyrano in Roundabout's production of Edmond Rostand's "Cyrano De Bergerac." Photo by Joan Marcus

The excitement with which his companions anticipate Cyrano's arrival energizes the already vibrant opening scene in "Cyrano De Bergerac." When he finally bursts in, Cyrano mesmerizes with the force of his outsized personality. Douglas Hodge embues Cyrano with so much gusto and fire that he seems to be a mythical hero.

Cyrano and Christian (Kyle Soller), a handsome newly recruited cadet are bonded by their rivalry for Roxanne's (Clémence Poésy) love.

Clémence Poésy as Roxanne, Kyle Soller as Christian with Douglas Hodge as Cyrano. Photo by Joan Marcus.

Edmond Rostand's gorgeous and enduring masterpiece of unrequited love gets a beautifully fluid verse translation from Ranjit Bolt in this gorgeous and opulent production.

Roxanne, taken by Christian's good looks, is even more intoxicated by the rapturous words of love Cyrano writes for him.  Cyrano and Christian share an allegiance that leads to sacrifice. The love in "Cyrano De Bergerac" is unconsummated, tender and wildly romantic.

Peter Bradbury, Jack  Cutmore-Scott, Douglas Hodge, Okeeriete Onaodowan, Samuel Roukin, Bill Buell, and Andy Grotelueschen in "Cyrano De Bergerac." Photo by Joan Marcus. 

In an excellent and extensive ensemble, Douglas Hodge is a marvel. His performance is both natural and incredible. His Cyrano is a gigantic and imposing figure. After a powerful performance as Spidey's over-miked nemesis, The Green Goblin,  Patrick Page plays a subtler role as a foppish villain, the Comte de Guiche, 

Jamie Lloyd's imaginative direction gives this "Cyrano De Bergerac" a feeling of accessibility. It's somehow akin to gourmet comfort food, familiar in its outlines, astounding in the details of its ingredients. The sets and costumes by Soutra Gilmour provide a lush and elegant backdrop on which Cyrano's touching story plays out. 

The physical also looms large in Samuel D. Hunter's "The Whale," at Playwrights Horizons through December 9th.

 In "The Whale,"Charlie (Shuler Hensley) is so grotesquely overweight that he can barely move around the epic dump (set by Mimi Lien) of an apartment in which he lives. His 600+ lbs have made breathing difficult and painful. Liz (Cassie Beck), his impromptu visiting nurse and friend, lovingly and disgustedly hurls abuse at him while she cares for him.   They are both aware that he is dying.

Like Cyrano, Charlie is a wordsmith. His job is to offer on-line tutorials on term papers. He is a very nonjudgmental teacher. Charlie is a softee with a rosy view of human potential and kindness. In contrast, all the women in his life are tough and angry.

Regina de Courcy, as Ellie, his strange and estranged teenage daughter, gives a brilliant portrayal of a smart and smart-mouthed misfit. Shuler Hensley makes this bleak tale of a man isolated in his immobility riveting.

Samuel D. Hunter's "The Whale"is a well-conceived play but Rostand's "Cyrano De Bergerac" is an iconic and soaringly wonderful with  beauty-and-the- beast themed work. The Roundabout has done it proud.

For more information on "The Whale," please visit Playwrights Horizons.

To learn more about the Roundabout and its production of  "Cyrano De Bergerac," please go to  Roundabout Theatre Company.